Stop Building the Case: Why Curious Leaders Get the Real Story

Key Takeaways

  • The Habit: Under pressure, most of us slip into prosecutor mode. We look for who did it, ask why, and gather evidence to reach a verdict we've already made.

  • The Reframe: Curiosity isn't going easy on performance. It's getting accurate data before you decide what the problem is.

  • The Practice: Four simple steps I come back to with the leaders I work with to help you close the gap between intent and impact when the stakes are high. (Catch Your Verdict, Put Your Assumption on the Stand, Trade the Trap Question for a Scientist's Question, and Name the Human Before You Fix the Problem)

Years ago, as a Principal, I rolled out a new program structure that shifted several people's roles. I'd thought it through. I believed in it. And then one of my teachers pushed back.

I'll be honest about the first story I told myself: She doesn't trust me. Before she'd finished her second sentence, I was already building my case. I had my reasons lined up, my rebuttals ready, and a quiet verdict forming about what her resistance said about our relationship.

But when I finally slowed down and got curious, I heard something I had missed completely. She wasn't questioning me. She was seeing ripple effects I hadn't seen, ways the change would land on our students. And she was right. I adjusted the structure so it had less of an impact on the student experience, and it was a better decision because she spoke up.

That moment taught me something I still carry into my work with leaders today. Pushback often isn't about trust. It's about information we don't have yet. And under pressure, most of us don't go looking for it. We go looking for proof.

The Problem: The Verdict Arrives Before the Evidence

In my work with leadership teams, I see three traps that quietly turn good intentions into friction.

  1. The Filter is when we stop listening and start judging.

  2. The Transaction is when we treat people like task machines and skip their humanity.

  3. And then there's the one I want to sit with today: The Prosecutor.

The Prosecutor trap is simple. We assume we already know why someone did what they did. Then we interrogate them instead of getting curious about their reality.

I see it most on teams that have worked together for years. Familiarity builds mental shortcuts. I already know why she's dragging her feet. She hates process. I know why he pushed back in that meeting. He's protecting his department.

The moment we're sure we know the reason, perspective-taking stops. We stop being a leader seeking clarity and start acting like an investigator confirming a guilty verdict. This is where intent vs. impact gets expensive. We intend to solve the problem quickly and hold the line on standards. The impact? The other person feels like they're on trial.

And people on trial don't share data. They defend themselves. They give you the plea, not the story.

So the real cause (an unclear handoff, a workload no one saw, a broken system) stays hidden. And the problem comes back next quarter.

If you're recognizing yourself here, I want to be gentle about this. None of this makes you a bad leader. It makes you a human one, under pressure.

Many of us were promoted because we spot problems quickly. Prosecutor mode is that same gift, pointed at people instead of processes.

We judge ourselves by our intentions. Our teams experience our impact.

What the Research Is Telling Us

In Think Again, organizational psychologist Adam Grant builds on Philip Tetlock's research to describe the mental modes we slip into: preachers defending our beliefs, prosecutors trying to prove others wrong, and politicians seeking approval. Grant's alternative is the scientist, who favors curiosity over conviction and treats a strongly held view as a hypothesis to test, not a verdict to defend.

I love this reframe. It takes so much weight off. A scientist doesn't run an experiment to prove they're right. They run it to find out what's true. Suddenly, pushback and missed deadlines stop looking like insubordination. They start looking like data.

The Scientist Shift: Four Steps to Lead With Curiosity Under Pressure

At Peak Leaders Collective, all four steps to respond as a scientist rest on three simple things: presence, perspective, and connection. None of this takes a big initiative. It takes a few small habits you can reach for when the temperature rises.

1. Catch Your Verdict

You can't set down an assumption you haven't noticed.

So before your next tense conversation, pause and name two things: the behavior that's frustrating you, and the story you're telling yourself about it.

Then ask the question that opens the door: if my assumption is only half true, or completely wrong, what else might be driving this? Workload. Unclear priorities. Something at home.

“My story is that they're____. If I'm wrong, what else could be going on?”

Action Item: Pick one persistent friction point with a direct report, peer, or another department. Write three lines: what happened, the story I'm telling myself, and what I might not be seeing yet.

2. Put Your Assumption on the Stand

This is where we turn the courtroom around. Instead of cross-examining the other person, cross-examine your own verdict.

It helps to have a thinking partner here. Ask someone you trust to play scientist for you and ask three questions: 

  • What do I actually know, and what am I assuming? 

  • If I were in their shoes on a chaotic day, what might this feel like? 

  • What's one curiosity-driven question I could ask them this week to test my hypothesis?

I'll be honest: this one can feel humbling. That's usually a sign it's working.

"I've got a theory about why this keeps happening, and I don't trust it yet. Can you help me poke holes in it?"

Action Item: Find someone you trust and ask them to be your scientist for ten minutes. Leave with one question you'll actually ask the other person.

3. Trade the Trap Question for a Scientist's Question

Here's something I've noticed. Prosecutor questions sound like questions, but they're really statements wearing a question mark. "Why didn't you follow the process?" assumes fault and asks for a plea.

Scientist questions are open and exploratory. They're aimed at the system, not the person's character. The difference isn't tone. It's purpose. The Prosecutor demands a plea. The Scientist gathers data so you can solve the problem together.

  • "Walk me through your timeline between Thursday and Friday. Where did the wheels come off?"

  • "What's the main roadblock you ran into? What are you seeing that I might be missing from where I sit?"

Action Item: Before your next one-on-one, rewrite your hardest "why didn't you" question as a "walk me through" question. After you ask it, hold a three-second silence. Let the answer land before you evaluate it.

4. Name the Human Before You Fix the Problem

Imagine your scientist question works. Someone finally tells you the truth. They're drowning, and they didn't think anyone would listen.

This is the moment I care about most. If your next sentence is a solution, you've gathered the data and skipped the person.

This is where dignity comes in. Two small things help: name the feeling you're hearing, and say back what you think the real issue is, so they know you got it. UCLA neuroscientist Matthew Lieberman's research on "affect labeling" suggests that putting feelings into words can quiet the brain's threat response.

"That's a lot. No wonder you're overwhelmed. Can I say back what I'm hearing? It sounds like the real issue is ____. Did I get that right?"

Validating a feeling isn't waiving accountability. You can hold high standards with deep safety. Both can be true at the same time.

Action Item: In your next tense conversation, name one feeling you hear, and say back one thing you heard before offering any solution.

The Reframe

Prosecutor mode isn't a character flaw. It's a stress habit. And habits can change.

When the pressure rises, your team isn't watching to see whether you find the culprit. They're watching to see whether it's safe to tell you the truth. That's the moment when the values on the wall meet real life.

Curiosity isn't soft. It's how you get the real story while there's still time to act. Drop the verdict. Run the experiment.

So I'll leave you with a gentle question.

Where is pressure pulling you toward a verdict right now? And what might you learn if you got curious instead?

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between prosecutor mode and scientist mode in leadership?

In prosecutor mode, a leader assumes they know why something went wrong and asks questions designed to confirm it. In scientist mode, a leader treats that first explanation as a hypothesis, asks open questions, and looks for the system-level causes behind the problem. The framing comes from Adam Grant's Think Again.

How can leaders stay curious under pressure?

Start by catching your verdict: name the assumption you're making and ask what else could explain the behavior. Then swap "why didn't you" questions for "walk me through" questions, name the emotion you hear, before moving to solutions.

What does intent vs impact mean for leaders?

Intent is what you meant to do. Impact is how others actually experience you. Leaders judge themselves by their intentions, while teams experience their impact. Under pressure, a good intention (fixing a problem fast) can land as blame or micromanagement.

At Peak Leaders Collective, we believe leadership is human work. The best leaders don't lower the bar when things get hard. They raise their curiosity. If you'd like to see where trust is strongest on your team, and where pressure may be pulling you toward the courtroom, our free High-Trust Leader Index is a good place to start.

Next
Next

Difficult Conversations: How to Move Past The Cushion and The Hammer into The Sweet Spot